The Cost of Staying Independent

$47-per-yard silk lining. Seashell buttons that cost 65 cents each. For Preston Williams, co-founder and creative director of SHERMAN | PRESTON, those details point to the question behind every independent fashion brand: When every design decision carries a financial cost, what is worth protecting?


For independent fashion brands, every creative decision comes with a price. SHERMAN | PRESTON co-founder Preston Williams explains what it takes to protect a brand’s identity when quality, craftsmanship, and financial reality collide.

“I want the silk lining,” Williams said. “Yes, I know it’s $47 a yard, and each jacket is going to be about a yard and a half. I know. Yes, I know the seashell buttons are 65 cents, and we need to keep it at 15 cents a button.”

“I know, but also, look at the difference,” he continued. “You can tell, but does the consumer care?”

For Williams, answering that question has been part of building SHERMAN | PRESTON from the beginning.

“One thing that we definitely knew was we wanted to do it ourselves, with our own money, with our own insight,” Williams said. “There’s no rich uncle behind this. It’s really blood, sweat and tears.”

For independent designers, sourcing, materials, manufacturing and pricing become part of the creative process, especially without the scale or capital of a larger company. Remaining independent often means deciding which details define the brand, and which can change without altering what the customer experiences.


Building the brand independently

The New York-based menswear label SHERMAN | PRESTON grew from Fame’s Allure, a blog and creative collective Williams and Sherman Joseph developed in college. Its early years were marked by trial, error, self-education, and financial risk.

Williams has discussed the company’s early development in a CanvasRebel interview, but the financial foundation of the brand is straightforward. The founders funded the label while maintaining professional careers outside the brand. Williams leads much of the creative work, while Joseph approaches decisions through finance and operations.

Fashion educator and consultant Michelle Alleyne says those financial pressures begin before a garment reaches production.

“I always push my clients to write a business plan,” Alleyne said. “Have a plan, know what you’re doing, understand the market, so that you can understand the cost.”

“I don’t think they are considering the product-development costs—like patternmaking and sampling, and reiterating, making new samples and making changes,” she continued.

By the time some designers reach production, Alleyne said, they have already spent more than expected.

“There’s a lot of outlay before you even make a dime,” she said. “That’s the problem.”

Every design decision—from buttons to stitching—is weighed against production costs without losing the brand's identity.


Local Production, Higher Stakes

For SHERMAN | PRESTON, independence also shaped where and how the clothes were made. Williams said the brand sourced fabrics and components in New York’s Garment District, seeking everything from thread to shoulder pads within the city.

“We were spending the money to buy the fabric in New York,” Williams said. “We sourced locally; we worked with everyone locally. The artisans that we worked with were all local.”

Alleyne said small-batch manufacturing helps explain why local production can be more expensive.

“Usually local production is smaller factories, and manufacturing is based on economies of scale,” she said. “The more you produce, the cheaper everything becomes.”

“If I make 50 of a garment versus 5,000 of a garment, I’m paying completely different prices,” Alleyne said.

The tradeoff is greater control over the product.

“You’re closer to your work, so you can be quality control and go in there and fix problems,” Alleyne said. “The closer you are to them, you can go in and mitigate those issues. That is a huge benefit.”

Material selection is both a creative and financial decision, influencing quality, price, and production.


What is worth protecting?

Williams describes the design process as a negotiation between what distinguishes the brand and what customers are willing to pay for.

“If it’s working over here and it’s a proven fact over here, why are we going the extra mile?” Williams recalled Joseph asking. “And I’d come back to him and say, ‘Well, this is why we’re SHERMAN | PRESTON.’”

But that distinction still has to matter to the customer.

“Does the client care that the lining is silk, so therefore they’re paying a bit more?” Williams said. “Or are they just like, ‘No, I just want the brand and the style. I don’t care about that. Give it to me for a better price.’”

Alleyne approaches the same problem from the production side.

“I always recommend a cost sheet where the designer or the production person can plug in the numbers and see where it lands even before they start developing the product,” she said. “Do the math first,” Alleyne continued. “Do the math first, so you understand whether or not your customer will pay for that.”

Compromise, she argues, does not always have to change the garment’s visible identity.

“Change the components. Shift the components to something that’s more affordable,” Alleyne said. “It doesn’t have to be the outside of the garment.”

“Nothing is bigger than the brand,” Williams said. “It doesn’t matter so much what we design as long as it’s real to us and it’s natural to us, and we love it.”

For Williams, protecting that feeling ultimately means protecting the story behind the clothes.

“The story has to mean something,” Williams said. “The clothes are just the clothes. The clothes tell the time frame of where we were. SHERMAN | PRESTON is what I would want men to dress like today. While you were wearing SHERMAN | PRESTON, what did you do? Where did you go?”

The challenge is making sure that feeling can still exist after the cost sheet has had its say.